Excel vs TMS: When Should Small Carriers Make the Switch?

Excel feels free and familiar — but it costs small carriers more than they realize. Here's when to switch to a proper TMS.

The Hidden Cost of Excel

Almost every small carrier starts with Excel. It's free, everyone knows it, and it works — at least in the beginning. But as your operation grows, Excel starts costing you more than you realize.

Here's what "free" Excel actually costs a typical small carrier with 3 trucks:

  • 2-3 hours/week re-entering load data from Timocom into spreadsheets
  • 1-2 hours/week manually creating invoices from load data
  • Errors — wrong prices, missed loads, double-billing
  • No visibility — can't quickly see which loads are pending, in transit, or completed
  • No driver tracking — who is where, with which truck?

At €30/hour, 4 hours/week of admin work = €480/month in labour costs. The "free" spreadsheet isn't free at all.

Signs You've Outgrown Excel

You're ready for a TMS when you recognize these situations:

  • You have more than 20 loads per month and it's getting hard to track status
  • Invoicing takes you more than 30 minutes per week
  • You've had at least one billing mistake in the last 3 months
  • Your driver asks you "which load do I have today?" and you have to search through spreadsheets
  • You can't quickly answer "how much did we earn last month?"

If three or more of these apply to you, a TMS will pay for itself within 30 days.

What Changes When You Switch to a TMS

The immediate difference is time. With Cargon TMS, importing a Timocom load takes 30 seconds instead of 5 minutes. Generating an invoice is one click instead of 20 minutes of copy-pasting.

The longer-term difference is visibility. A TMS shows you in real time:

  • Revenue per load and per month
  • Margin on each transport (what you charged vs what you paid the carrier)
  • Which clients give you the most profitable routes
  • Upcoming license and maintenance deadlines for your fleet

The Switch is Easier Than You Think

Most small carriers worry about migrating their data and learning new software. In practice, you can be operational in Cargon within an hour. The interface is designed to be intuitive — if you can use Excel, you can use Cargon.

You don't need to migrate historical data. Start fresh with new loads from today, and keep your old spreadsheets for historical reference.

Buy Now →